Quality Consumers Goods - Free Essay Example

Sample details Pages: 32 Words: 9480 Downloads: 1 Date added: 2017/06/26 Category Statistics Essay Did you like this example? In recent years, consumers are becoming increasingly conscious about the quality, safety, suitability and environmental impacts of the goods that they demand. However, in many cases, consumers would not aware of the quality of a goods or products even after consumptions. These products are known as the credence goods. Don’t waste time! Our writers will create an original "Quality Consumers Goods" essay for you Create order It is difficult to distinguish between two qualities of the same good, even after consumption. In such case, consumers are willing to pay a premium for the hidden attributes of the goods that they cannot observe. Such goods include natural versus genetically modified (GM) food, organic versus non-organic products, fair-trade products, suitable for vegetarians goods, Kosher, and more generally high-quality versus low-quality products. However, this paper is interested to study a special type of credence goods, that is Halal versus non-Halal products or goods. Halal is an Arabic word which means lawful or permissible. It follows the Islamic ruling known as the Syariah law. Halal covers every aspect of Muslims life especially dietary. Halal food simply means that the food products are free from any elements which Muslims prohibited from consuming. Extended discussion on Halal is presented in Chapter 2. With Islam as the second largest religion in the world and the fastest growing, the world Halal food trade is estimated to be around US$ 150 billion to US$ 500 billion in 2007 on which US$ 80 billion alone is generated from agri-food products (Agriculture and Agri-food Canada, 2007; Brunei Halal, 2007). These factors hasten the investment in Halal products, and in some cases, producers cheat for easy access to the market. Analysis of Halal in this paper, distinguishes itself from other studies on credence goods, as it involves different levels of consumers interactions. Any credence goods, including Halal products, comprise a special attribute or characteristic. This characteristic is not verifiable and revealed unless by experts or other professional services. Hahn (2004) suggested that real or complete credence goods would be difficult to find as consumers would have some judgement on products or services after the consumption. This is not entirely true as in case of Halal food product, especially Halal meat. It is very difficult to check if the meat is entirely Halal as claimed, as there is no existing way to check after consumption whether say the meat purchased is really slaughtered in Syariah methods, even though there is non-existence of other non-Halal ingredients. Therefore, in this sense, Halal meat is an example of a real credence good. In many cases, consumers concern for the special or credence attribute (eg. environmental, fair-trade, organic, Halal, etc.) is evidenced by their willingness to pay a premium for the high-quality products. The willingness to pay opens up an opportunity for low-quality producers (those which lack the special attribute) to take advantage by pretending to be that of high-quality, especially when only the producers know whether the desirable attribute exist in their products or not. Moreover, it is too expensive for individual consumer to directly monitor or verify these attributes. Therefore, consumers could only decide their purchasing choice on subjective belief regarding the products quality, which are based on all available information such as press report, word-of-mouth and labels when such adverse selection in credence goods market exist. Hence, producers cannot build reputation when production of low-quality imitating goods could not be detected and punished. Delayed detection of low-quality products allows its producers to imitate the strategy of their high-quality rivals, which hampered signalling use. Like other credence goods, Halal food products, through certified Halal brand/logo would improve the information asymmetry, but may carry the similar issues. These issues are discussed in Chapter 2. It is common for credence goods to feature a communication scheme such as labels or brands to help consumers in making purchasing decisions. Moreover, these labels or brands often require authentication by legislator or a third-party organisations that have the proficiency in each field of specific credence quality attributes, thus involving additional costs. In the Halal market, there also exist regulations by the government (eg. in Brunei, under the authority of Brunei Islamic Religious Council, Ministry of Religious Affairs) or third party organisation (eg. in United Kingdom, by Halal Monitoring Committee and Halal Food Authority, to name some). In which they certify a product through monitoring and indicating some guidelines for producers before granting a recognisable label on the products. Hence, this label helps consumers to make better decision choice. Moreover, a quality label that improves pre-purchasing information would increase welfare, and high-quality producers would always be willing to go through the necessary inspection as to reveal the products quality to the consumers, unless the cost for verification is extremely high. The welfare affect of introducing Halal labelling is briefly discussed in the analysis, especially where Halal labelling opens up an opportunity to access additional consumers, ie. Muslims, also referre d to the primary consumers. The analysis of Halal in this paper is aimed to study the interactions of the market forces or what commonly referred to in economics as invisible hand of the demand and supply in Halal market. At the same time, considering the effects on introduction of labelling upon the level of equilibrium, in addition to other factors such as the additional demand by Muslims of primary market. This is a unique or special aspect which might not be available in previous studies on credence goods. The following chapters are organised as follows. Halal concept is further discussed in the next Chapter 2. This chapter is intended as an expansion to the introduction (Chapter 1) in order to provide a deeper understanding on the concept of Halal, and to provide information regarding the current market for Halal food products and the issues pertaining in the Halal market on the use of Halal logo. The relevant literature reviews are discussed in Chapter 3, discussing the works by other authors on the area of credence goods which can be linked to Halal. Chapter 4 presents the economic analysis and application of Halal products as credence goods. Chapter 5 concludes this paper and provide a discussion on the policy implications generated by the study. CHAPTER 2 2.0. A Brief Concept of Halal Religion involves beliefs and the way of life, where group of individuals interprets and respond to what they feel is supernatural and holy (Johnstones, 1975, in Shafie and Othman, n.d.). Shafie and Othman underline that most religion prescribes or prohibits certain behaviour including that of consumption (n.d.). The concept of Halal is not new in the Islamic world, but only in recent years that its potentials have been realised by corporations and organisations around the world, which normally perform under the conventional economics. The word Halal comes from Arabic which means permissible or lawful. It is ruled by the Islamic law known as Syariah law which is based on the Quran and Hadith (records of the life, actions and teachings of Prophet Muhammad). By not fully understanding the concept of Halal, one (non-Muslim especially in Muslim-minority country such as United Kingdom) may think that Halal only refers to meat or something to do with kebabs. Halal actually governs every aspect of life of Muslims, however, this paper only view Halal perspective on consumption of food. What is not Halal is called Haram or non-permissible. Any product which comes from swine and/or dog is strictly Haram. A special cleansing ritual must be done if a Muslim directly touched (although accidentally) these animals and/or the sources (eg. skin). Such products that contain strictly Haram ingredients or derivatives are termed as non-transformable in the analysis in Chapter 4. Amongst other strictly Haram animal products include blood, birds of prey, and/or carrion (dead animals without slaughtering). Alcohol is also Haram, but in some strict case it could become or change into Halal, this is discussed later on in Section 2.3 of this paper. Un-slaughtered animals such as beef and chicken are also become non-Halal, unless slaughtered by a Muslim according to Syariah practice. Such products are termed as transformable in the analysis of this paper. What lies between Halal and Haram is called Mashbooh meaning that the goods appear to be suspicious, questionable and According to Bonne and Verbeke (2007), as product attribute, Halal refers to the nature, origin and the processing methods of the food products, which entails similarity with organic foods and those taking animal welfare or sustainability into account. Strict procedure must be followed to obtain highest standard of Halal, and that Halal products must not contact with non-Halal products; as similar to vegetarian food should not be in contact with any meat. Halal concept covers both food and non-food product category, but as mentioned earlier, this paper would only focus on the first one. Studies show that about 70 to 75 percent of Muslim strictly follows the Halal standard for their dietary (Hussaini 1993a in Bonne and Verbeke, 2007; Minkus-McKenna, 2007). The next section provides an overview of Halal food market. 2.1. Halal Food Market The Halal market is considered as the fastest growing market globally as reported by the Borneo Bulletin (2008). The world Halal industry is estimated to worth between US$ 500 million to around US$ 2 trillion (Agriculture and Agri-food Canada, 2007; Borneo Bulletin, 2008; Brunei Halal, 2007). The market is growing around US$ 500 billion annually due to the rising Muslim population worldwide (Borneo Bulletin, 2008; Brunei Halal, 2007). It is reported that the Muslim population is known to be the fastest growing religion in the world (Bonne and Verbeke, 2007) and in Europe (BBC News, 2005). The global Halal food trade itself in 2007 is estimated to be between US$ 150 billion (Brunei Halal, 2007) and US$500 billion with 12 percent of this or US$ 80 billion generated from agri-food products (Agriculture and Agri-food Canada, 2007). In addition, Islam is the second largest religion in the world (Riaz and Chaudry, 2004) with nearly 1.5 billion people (ibid.; Bonne and Verbeke, 2007; Din, 2006). The National Statistics Census carried out by the British Government, shows that Islam is also the second largest religion in the United Kingdom, approximately 1.6 million Muslims (2001). The statistics also revealed that Muslims are the largest household in the United Kingdom. These factors would justify that the demand for Halal food products in the United Kingdom is expanding. The market for Halal can be divided into two namely, primary and secondary. Primary market arises from the demand by Muslims, whereas, secondary market refers to the demand by non-Muslims. These terms are used in the analysis of this paper. Agriculture and Agri-food Canada (2007) suggested that Halal is often referred to safety and of high quality by both markets. Besides these, factors for increasing Halal demand includes: increasing incomes in primary market, rising population of Muslim, and rising demand for variety in primary market (ibid.). For Muslims, consuming Halal food products are their religious obligation, however it is known that Halal food are also consumed by non-Muslims. The later often perceived as specially selected and processed to achieve highest standards of quality (Riaz and Chaudry, 2004, p. 14). Manufacturers or producers that sells Halal products would create significant advantage compared to those that do not (Shafie and Othman, n.d.). Riaz and Chaudry (2004, p. 16) suggested that the increasing demand for Halal products as well as expanding number of Muslim population can be an inducement for producers to provide Halal products. Nonetheless, it is safe to say that these views mostly look at Muslim-majority economies such as those in Asian region. Hence, this paper provides a study in relation to Muslim-minority economy such as the United Kingdom. However, like any other food labels, Halal labelling also have some issues. 2.2. Halal Logo and Its Issues The use of Halal logo in food products indicates that the products are Islamic or Syariah compliant. Similar to other food related logos such as suitable for vegetarian V-logo, Halal logo intends to communicate with the consumers of this product that it is fit for their consumption. Initial finding shows that some companies may use this logo even though its products might violate some rules of the Syariah law. Such situation was reported in which, some meat and other processed products from Brazil imported into the country, were being inspected by Halal Monitoring Committee, to be found a violation (2007). Another comparable situation is reported by The Tribune (2008) that the biggest meat producer in Scotland is under investigation over the supply of so-called fake Halal meat in the country. There are some issues to which cause the problem arises. Fischer claims that the lack of a state body that is capable of inspecting the unregulated market [in the United Kingdom] has left this market open to fraud, corruption and without any kind of standards, uniform certification and standard (n.d.). Study by Fischer also shows that many British Muslims and organisations call upon the state to help recognise and standardised Halal. However for the ease of this papers analysis, this situation is relaxed, meaning producers behave honestly when claiming their products as Halal. Having Halal logo does not mean the products automatically accepted to be purchased by consumers especially that of primary market. Research undertaken by a university in the United Kingdom, shows that consumers prefer small shops when buying Halal meat, rather than buying from supermarkets, due to factors mentioned earlier and others including lack of marketing of Halal food (Anonymous, 2006). Like any other goods, the credence of Halal food products has to be clearly communicated such as indication on pack or on-label (Bonne and Verbeke, 2007), in addition to conventional marketing strategies, for example advertising. Moreover, this would add some utility value to the consumer and useful in the purchasing decision (ibid.). Nonetheless, to make the analysis of this paper simple, having Halal labelling is enough to induce greater demand and consumptions. 2.3. Issues of Alcohol Alcohol is clearly not permissible, however it is essential for certain industry processes and religious scholars are aware of this some of them suggested that some use of alcohol may be acceptable as long as it is evaporated and not exist in the final products (Riaz and Chaudry, 2004). However, if there is an alternative to alcohol for such process, it would be preferred, as majority of Muslims would avoid products that use alcohol at any stage. It is generally known by Muslims that wine (a Haram state product) which turns naturally into vinegar thus the vinegar is considered as Halal. This situation is called Istihala or change of state or properties. A reverse situation as such that, if wine is added to Halal food, as in common cooking practise in the Western, hence the food becomes Haram. However, this issue is not represented in the analysis, for simplicity argument. It is clear that Halal can be perceived as a credence attribute, although there are numerous literatures on cred ence goods, only few actually discussed in relation to Halal products. Next chapter will discuss the literatures on credence products. CHAPTER 3 3.0. Literature Review This chapter is divided into five interrelated parts or sections. The first section provides a (general) glance on the studies or literatures on credence goods, which is applicable in the study of the market for Halal products. This is followed by the second section, of discussions on the demand for such goods. Market failure arises due to the nature of credence goods, which is discussed in the third section of this chapter. In the fourth section, a review on the solution of the market failure problem is examined. The final section deals with the issue pertaining to some of these solutions. 3.1. Credence Goods at a Glance There are growing numbers of literatures on credence goods attribute since it was first mentioned by Darby and Karni in 1973. These literatures involve different assumptions which produce diverse outcomes. However, it is difficult to find economic literature that deals directly with Halal subject as a credence good. Nonetheless, studies on some of the credence goods can be applied to Halal concept. Most literatures on credence goods assume that consumers are homogeneous. Hahn (2004) showed the contrast to this, in which the author grouped the consumers into two namely those who have some expertise or informed and those who do not or uninformed; This paper is slightly differs from that of Hahn (2004), where the consumers in this paper are also divided into two, namely Muslims (those who only consume Halal goods, or primary consumers) and non-Muslims. The latter is further grouped into two, ie. conventional consumerswho only consume non-Halal; and secondary consumerswho prefer to consume Halal products. Some economists (such as McCluskey, 2000; Cho and Hooker, 2002) used game theory models on credence attribute to assess the interplays of stakeholders. These include whether producers decide to claim their products as those of high quality, then they have to decide whether to produce according to the claims or not. However, the use of game theory is out of the scope of this papers analysis. Nonetheless, producers are assumed to produce what they intended to, without dishonesty. Economists divide consumers perception of food quality into a three attributes, namely: search, experience (which were pioneered by Nelson in 1970) and credence attribute (in Darby and Karni, 1973; Innes et. al., 2007; Umberger et. al., 2008). Search attributes can be determined from pre-consumption and at point of purchase such as colour, shape, brand and freshness. Experience attributes, arise from taste, juiciness, and food safety which could only be determined during or after consumption. Lastly, credence attributes refer to the process and production aspects, which the author claims that it cannot be determined before, during or after consumption of that particular food product (Umberger et. al., 2008). These food products, especially Halal as credence goods emphasise and maintain a strict quality attributes, and failure to maintain this would result a loss in its credibility, hence would brings disutility to the consumers or reduction of welfare. Some economists such as Caswell and Mojduszka (1996, in Cho and Hooker, 2002) argued that by providing information as policy tool, credence attributes could be transformed into search attributes. However, this would require a strict environment where system of information provided is perfect and fraud could not taken place these are less likely to be a (current) scenario of the real world. Nonetheless, this concept is used in the analysis of this paper, for simplicity reason. On the other hand, Cho and Hooker (2002) mentioned that credence goods could act like a (lagged) experience goods if they involve time duration for detection of risk (relatively quickly), eg. infected food, vice versa. Like any production or supply of consumer goods, it depends on the demand for such goods, for an equilibrium to exist in the market. The following section discusses the determinants of demand for credence goods. 3.2. Consumer Demand for Credence Attribute Individuals would consume goods or services that yields highest utility or satisfaction level and presumed to make rational choice. However, this is subject to physical (ie. how much they can consume) and economic (ie. budget) constraint that limits the consumers choices (Mas-Colell et. al., 1995). Moreover, the preference-based approach to consumer demand is of critical importance for welfare analysis in which, without it, evaluating the consumers level of well-being would have no meaning (ibid.). Dulleck and Kerschbamer (2001) identified credence characteristics in terms of utility, in which although consumers can observe the utility derived from consumption of such goods ex post, they are not sure if the utility they get is the ex ante needed one. However, in the analysis of this paper, the utility is considered in terms of welfare level obtained from consumers and producers surplus. In addition to the conventional determinants for demand such as income, taste and preference, consumer characteristics and quality attribute become increasingly important factors nowadays. According to Antle (1999, in Senauer, 2001, p. 4), the new economics is more concerned with the markets for quality-differentiated products in which the author presented a stylised demand function which include quality factors (non-price attribute): X = D (P, I, N, C, Q) Where X depends on price and other goods (P), income (I), number of population (N), characteristics of the population/consumer (C), and non-price attribute of the product (Q). It shows that any product attribute which includes nutrition content, safety, production process and even inputs, would creates utility or disutility. The analysis in Chapter 4 directly deals with the two of these factors namely, consumer characteristics (ie. preferences, and religious needs) and product attribute (ie. Halal credence). Hoehn and Deaton (2004) provided a model where consumers choose either purchasing credence (high-quality) good or conventional (low-quality) goods by comparing the consumer surplus differences. If the gain from consumer surplus from credence goods is large, compared to the opportunity cost of surplus given up from not purchasing conventional goods, the former good would be purchased. Their studies are used as a foundation for the analysis in Chapter 4 of this paper. Most literature reflects credence goods as vertically differentiated products due to quality differences. Nonetheless, Bester (n.d., in Roe and Sheldon, 2001) provided a concept of unobserved quality into a horizontal differentiation model and suggested that unobserved vertical quality would reduce producers incentives for horizontal differentiation via relaxing price competition amongst producers, in a way which prices act as a signal and consist of a quality premium. This is related to the second part of this papers analysis (Section 4.2. of Chapter 4) involving a franchise market. Consumers demand and preferences for credence goods often perceived from their willingness to pay. 3.2.1. Willingness to Pay There are other factors why consumers might be willing to pay a premium besides the quality attribute, such that they perceive credence goods as fashionable, trendy, or it could be that the purchase the alternative to credence goods would offend other people (McCluskey, 2000). The later is pertinent to Halal goods, especially in a situation where the consumer lives with Muslims housemates, or in a Muslim-dominated country. Consumers would also prefer for the high-quality products, even not for the sake of quality itself but other factors. For instance, when consumers care about other quality or criterion such as animal welfare, environmental, ethical, and religious reasons, to what Antle (1999, in Carlsson et. al., 2004) referred as extrinsic quality. If the distinctions in quality were signalled efficiently, consumers would be willing to pay a higher price or premium for products of high quality, hence compensating the higher production costs, as suggested by Kola and Latvala (2003). In their research on the effects of information on the demand for beef products credence characteristics in Finland, 59 percent of the respondents showed their willingness to pay a higher price for additional information. Whereas, 41 percent of respondents had zero willingness to pay, in which 35 percent of them are satisfied with the existing information, and 17 percent considered the information is not enough or they did not trust the information. As credence quality of a product cannot be observed directly at a reasonable cost or without invasive testing, consumers would rely heavily on claims or information made by the producers via brands, labels or advertisements (Cho and Hooker, 2002). This papers analysis however, only considers that consumers fully trust producers. The next section provides discussion if the information provided is insufficient or inaccurate, resulting a market failure. 3.3. Market Failure It can be said that the credence market are prone to the problems of market failure. There are different ways for a credence market to result in inefficiency. It is mainly due to information asymmetry between producers and consumers. 3.3.1. Information Asymmetry In credence goods, consumers cannot directly observe the quality of the goods that they consume where only the producers know the exact quality, thus resulting information asymmetry. Common intuition indicates that the solution for an information asymmetry is by providing more information. Information, as conferred by Weiss (1995, in Cho and Hooker, 2002) is the central tenet of food safety economics. Brands, logos and labels most importantly serve as a signal to inform and communicate to the consumers about products attributes, hence alleviating information asymmetry between producers and consumers. According to Verbeke (2005), information is likely to be effective only when it addresses specific information needs of its target audience. It requires identification and detailed understanding of these needs, and proper management on the provision of the information in order to optimally address the needs (ibid.). Information regarding food quality and safety can be categorised as risk information and aims at reducing uncertainty faced by the consumers in making purchasing decisions. Hence, success would come from better understanding regarding consumers attitude, behaviour, motives, and their perceptions (Frewer et. al., 2004, in Verbeke, 2005). There exist welfare effects to consumers for providing (Marette et. al., 1999, in ibid.) or withholding (Mazzocchi et. al., 2004b, in ibid.) food quality information. The work done by Umberger (et. al., 2008), can be used as a foundation on the argument for the importance of Halal logo or labelling on food products in particular. The authors claimed that potential market failure would occur if consumers face limited choice and if the access to innovative products is not available, or information regarding product attributes, for example the production methods, is not transparent (ibid.). With this regards, Halal products would be seen as innovative products and carry some product attributes that must be fulfilled, otherwise there might exist market failure for Halal products. Halal logo especially from organisation for Halal certification, could be used to indicate these attributes. Consequently, lack of information becomes the key factor for the inefficiency of credence market. The followings are resulted from insufficient information. 3.3.1A. Failure due to Fraud In their studies, Dulleck and Kerschbamer (2001) divided credence attribute problems into two fold: inefficiency treatment, and overcharging. The first fold refers to the quality level (or service) of credence goods provided by producers, and inefficiency treatment can be either under- or over-treatment. On the other hand, the second fold refers to the pricing of credence goods, particularly as self-described, overcharging. When the signal is unavailable, especially in the case where labelling is not mandatory, sellers may have the incentive to fraud by supplying products of low-quality but claiming these products as high quality. Akerlof (1970) explains this situation with automobiles market as an example, in which with asymmetric information high-quality goods (peach) would be driven out by the low-quality goods (lemons) hence resulting market failure. Moreover, as argued by Liebie (2002), when producers of low-quality products claim to be of high-quality, this would raise doubt in consumers mind and would not be willing to pay a premium for the high-quality goods. This in turns, would lower the profits of high-quality producer hence reducing their incentive to invest in high-quality products, in which would create further doubt to consumer. The cycle goes on until only low-quality products would be sold, even though consumers prefer high-quality products, resulting market failure. Darby and Karni (1973) suggested that the amount of fraud depends on reputation, market conditions, and technological factors. Profit-maximising producers would have the incentive to fraud by claiming their products are of high quality if the probability of not being caught is high enough (McCluskey, 2000) or conversely if the probability of being caught is low. Such fraud issues bring uncertainty to consumers. 3.3.1B. Problems of Uncertainty Bonroy and Constantos (2008) concluded that uncertainty by consumers on the identity of producers which produce the high-quality products put the high-quality producers in disadvantage resulting from higher cost. They argued that this disadvantage would remain even when the consumption of high-quality products benefits are well worth the cost difference and all beliefs regarding the high-quality producers are in the right direction (ibid.). Their model explains the difficulty faced by high-quality credence products to acquire the dominant market share they should have obtained from efficiency perspective (ibid.). This is however beyond the concept of this paper, as to avoid complication in the model, it is assumed that producers behave honestly in producing the products and consumers fully aware the qualities. 3.3.1C. Non-Rational Behaviour Unavailability of credible food quality labelling, consumers would face uncertainty and would incur search cost on specific information (Hobbs, 2004, in Verbeke 2005). As a result some consumers would not behave rationally, being ignorant, or make decisions which are not maximising their expected utility. Such behaviour explained as a concept of bounded and limited rationality or rationally ignorant consumer hypothesis (as found in Kahneman and Tversky, 1973; Simon 1979a,b; Camerer and Loewenstein, 2004; in Verbeke 2005), is however beyond the concept of the study in this paper. Verbeke (2005) concluded that without quality verification, traceability was of little value to consumers, whereas quality assurances were much more valuable to them. The solutions to the problems of market failure are presented in the next section. 3.4. Solutions to the Problems This section examines some of the solutions to the problems mentioned previously which are mainly caused by lack of information. The most common solution this, as stated earlier, is providing more information through labelling or signalling. But this must be accompanied with efficient monitoring. 3.4.1. The Use of Labelling as a Signal It is generally known that labelling of credence attribute could be used as a way to certify the provision of valued attributes, hence to avoid market failure. Moreover, Caswell and Padberg (1992) claimed that information in the form of labels, word-of-mouth, advertising, and education would contribute to the completeness and accuracy of assessment by consumer concerning these attributes. Spence (1973, in McCluskey 2000) provided an analysis on the use of signalling, where workers use education expenditure to indicate their type. Labelling schemes are reasonably specific because of their potential direct impact on consumers purchase decisions, which have a function as a cue that can be integrated by consumers in their assessment of alternative products (Verbeke, 2005). Hence, looking at the use of Halal labelling/logo, it serves as additional information on alternative goods (Halal products) from the non-Halal or conventional goods, especially for consumers in the primary market. Innes (et. al., 2007) distinguished between labels and brands, in which the former identifies a specific product characteristics pertaining only and precisely to the product itself, for example origin or composition. On the other hand, the author claims that brands is a broader concept which captures the product characteristics, reputation, and the accumulated consumer experience with that brand name or symbol that is viewed at the point of purchase. For the purpose of this research, the use of terms brand and label are integrated, unless otherwise told. Reo and Sheldon (2001) split labelling of credence goods into two forms namely: continuous and binary labelling. Continuous labelling referred to those credence attribute exist in consumer durable goods, for example refrigerator or air-conditioner that meet the energy efficiency, environmental friendly and using non-CFC gas. While binary labelling refers to non-durable consumer goods such as organic food, free-trade goods, free-range products, etc. This paper only uses the term labelling which refers to the binary labelling in this sense, as this paper study the area of Halal food products. Their studies also show that consumer welfare could improve through credence goods labelling as long as the administrative cost is not excessively high. A perfect substitute for credence goods would be the conventional goods without the credence attribute in terms of consumers direct experience (Hoehn and Deaton, 2004). Moreover, without the labelling, the two types of goods appeared to be indistinguishable (ibid.). However, this is not fully the case for Halal products especially for the consumers in the primary market (Muslims) as these consumers cannot substitute Halal products with non-Halal (conventional). Nonetheless, this is applicable for secondary market for Halal products. Hoehn and Deaton (2004) provided an analysis and illustrations on the affects of labelling of credence good on price, quantity, and welfare, by examining with pooled and separating equilibria concepts. They referred pooled equilibrium when the market has mixed goods of high-quality (green) and low-quality (conventional) products; whereas, separating equilibrium exist when credence labelling is introduced, the market becomes two different markets. Thus, economic consequences of labelling high-quality goods are high in value to consumers and low in value for conventional goods, which the later is even lower compared to when the goods are in the market of pooled equilibrium. Moreover, they suggested that labelling provides the high-quality goods producers a routine incentive to realise gains as the expense of low-quality producers. However, this is not entirely the case in the Halal market, where introduction of Halal labelling can be perceived not to compete for the existing consumers of conventional non-Halal goods; but to serve mainly for Muslim consumers whose would never consume the conventional goods. Their analysis is expanded in Chapter 4. Sedjo and Swallow (2002) also produced a graphical illustration in their analysis on the market implication of labelling consumer products (eco-labelled wood). Their analysis indicated that with some reasonable circumstances, some portion of consumers are willing to pay a price premium, yet a price differential may not arise. In addition, the authors claimed that, price premium would not arise although there exist substantial willingness to pay a premium (in voluntary labelling system), if demand of the high-quality is small compared to overall demand, certification costs are insignificant, and the additional demand is modest. This situation is also used in the second part of this paper (in Section 4.2), with slightly different settings. While labelling the whole product lines create benefit from consumers positive experience and may spread to other products bearing the same label, the reverse could also occur when consumers had negative experience of a product, affecting the other products of same line (Liebie, 2002). In relation to Halal logo/labelling, this situation is partly true especially under self-labelling. But if the producer uses certified third-party Halal labelling and cheats by not meeting the standard, it is most likely that only particular products under the producers brand is doubted and not other producers bearing the same third-party Halal logo. Again, this complication is avoided in the analysis as producers are assumed to be honest and information is perfect. 3.4.2. Solutions to the Problem of Fraud Dulleck and Kerschbamer (2001) provided an analysis to what they called a unified framework on the majority of specific models of credence goods, in which the market institution could eliminate without cost, the problem of fraud by producers if there exist three factors. First, if the consumers are homogeneous; second, if the economies of scope between diagnosis and treatment are large; and third, if the treatment is verifiable. Sufficient penalty could be used to minimise incentives for producers to fake their products quality, in addition to greater level of monitoring to increase the probability of dishonest producers to be penalised. Additionally in the real world, such fraud activity is a serious offence specifically with reference to Halal market especially of Muslim-majority economies. In most cases when producers were found faking by selling non-Halal goods, their business licences would be revoked, their business reputations are damaged, and bankruptcies are usually the common end result. This is because, once the producer is not trusted, Muslim consumers would not purchase the products from that producer (ie. boycott) and this could also be expected to create a ripple effect on the other (non-Muslim) consumers, similar to the cycle described by Liebie (2002) in Sub-Section 3.3.1A. Halal certificate would also be withdrawn if the production premise is not up to the certification standard, such as safety and cleanliness which would affect the products quality. This indicates that the level of monitoring must be adequate. 3.4.3. Monitoring of Labelling For a credence good (organic) market to be efficient, McCluskey (2000) suggest that it is necessary for a third-party agency to monitor the claims made by the producers. Moreover, there is a need for standardisation on the meaning and the term organic as this would reduce the cost of monitoring and enforcement (McCluskey, 2000). This is true in the sense of the term Halal, as there are many different criteria of Halal with different organisations which granted Halal certifications. Study by Fischer (n.d.) also shows that many British Muslims and organisations call upon the state to help recognise and standardised Halal. Nonetheless, for simplicity of the analysis of this paper (in Chapter 4), producers are assumed to be honest by introducing labels of true quality, eliminating the need for monitoring. In relation to organic foods as a credence good, McCluskey (2000) suggested producers may signal by allowing consumers to visit their premises to inspect production process. On the other hand, producers may obtain labels from a credible third-party agency, hence the labels act as a guarantee (McCluskey, 2000). The use of third-party labelling agency can be considered as costly compared to self-labelling by producers themselves, nonetheless, the later is considered as cheap talk (Baksi and Bose, 2007; Farrell, 1993, in McCluskey 2000), as no third-party to monitor their activities. Nonetheless, self-labelling is sufficient presumably where producers are honest in their actions, which is the case in the analysis of this paper. Furthermore, McCluskey (2000) claimed that if there is no monitoring for credence good, there would be no premium for claiming organic or high-quality products. However in practice, consumers are willing to pay a premium for these products even if there is no monitoring (especially if they are self-labelled) as consumers have some degree of trusting the producers, until legitimately proven wrong. The following final section discusses the limitations of the solutions to market failure of credence goods. 3.5. Limitations of the Solutions There are a number of limitations emerge around the solutions of inefficiency in credence goods market themselves. The solutions which are supposed to reduce inefficiency could become a double-edged sword if not treated well. The following sub-section briefly discussed some of them. 3.5.1. Inefficient Monitoring A study suggests that it could be economically effective in reducing search time and correcting asymmetric information that may exist between consumers and suppliers through labelling of credence attributes (Umberger et. al, 2008, pp. 5-6). However, the integrity of this labelling must be maintained otherwise, market failure would result. For instance, if private benefits from labelling exist (in such a way the products carry a Halal logo brings a premium in the market) but the cost of producing these attributes (maintaining Halal quality) are high, there could be incentives for producers to cheat by selling goods that are not up to Halal standards. These factors must also be considered by producers if they want to transform their production into Halal, as describe at the end of Chapter 4. Monitoring can only eliminate cheating if it is fully effective. Anania and Nistic (2003) provided a theoretical study on credence goods in which the incentive of low-quality producers to cheat depend on the level of effectiveness and credibility of public regulation in the provision of information to the consumers. Random inspections of high-quality would always reveal the true quality. Hence, if a producer of low-quality goods is caught faking the goods as of high-quality, hence a fine is imposed. Furthermore, in their model, the producers who had cheated would not be allowed to sell in the high-quality market, but the producers can still sell in the low-quality market where their products should belong. Since producers, in the analysis in Chapter 4, are assumed to be honest, the need for monitoring is eliminated. 3.5.2. Information Overload Another limitation is the level of information itself. As mentioned earlier, provision of more information will alleviate inefficiency caused by asymmetric information. Nonetheless, too much information would hinder the improvement of informational asymmetry especially for food products with credence attribute. According to Caswell and Padberg (1992), producers perceive limited regulation on labelling as desirable for maximum flexibility, nonetheless, excessive freedom would be detrimental, which undermine the credibility of producers communication, if it allows false claims. Selaun and Flores (2001, in Verbeke, 2005) pointed out that increasing amount of information on the label could overload the package, thus resulting consumers with limited time or ability to process such information to ignore the products resulting excess cost. Labelling in the analysis of this paper, is assumed to provides sufficient information and does not lead to information overload. The following Chapter 4 provides the economic analysis. CHAPTER 4 4.0. Economic Analysis The major assumptions in this analysis are as follows. Producer chooses either Halal (high-quality) or conventional (non-Halal or low-quality) products, and none of any combinations of the two types. For simplicity of analysis, the producers act honestly, ie. do not cheat by introducing fake labelling. The term labelling here also reflect the additional cost that would have been undergone by producers in producing or transforming into Halal production. Consumers on the other hand, perceive and trust the quality or types of goods exactly as informed by producers. In other words, information is perfect. Furthermore, it is assumed here that producers produce homogenous products and that some or all of the conventional products are transformable into Halal products (by following the Syariah compliant methods hence obtaining Halal logo as discussed in previous chapters). The welfare effects from introducing labelling, indicated by the consumers and producers surpluses, are briefly concluded at the end of this chapter. It is necessary to point out that the combinations of consumer types are different in each of the analysis. These types of consumers (interactions) can be illustrated as the following Diagram 2 below. The next Section 4.1. provides a basic foundation for the analysis. Subsequently, sub-section (4.1.1) only considers the left-side and the overlapped oval areas of the diagram below. An analysis with the inclusion of the right-side of the diagram is provided in sub-section (4.1.2). On the other hand, Section 4.2. only deals with the right-side and also the overlapped oval areas of Diagram 2. 4.1. Basic Model Studies by Hoehn and Deaton (2004) provided a foundation that can be applied into modelling of Halal (credence) products. Here, it can be assumed that all of the products are transformable. Following their analysis, the demand for conventional (non-Halal) products at a given price and at the absence of Halal logo is, (1) where is the demand for conventional products, is the demand intercept, is the slope of demand absolute value, is the price of conventional good. Hence, implies as the conventional product quantity demanded is a function of the price of conventional product. Here, equation (1) is referred as unconditional demand for conventional product. The reservation price schedule for conventional product is the inverse of Equation (1), thus, (2) where and corresponds to the reservation price as a function of quantity of unconditional conventional product. On the other hand, the unconditional demand for Halal product is therefore, (3) where is the willingness to pay (hereafter, WTP) by consumer for the (Halal) credence attribute per unit of the Halal product, which varies from zero to other positive value depending on consumer perception (eg. studies by Kola and Latvala, 2003). For simplicity of the analysis, is a real positive value and larger than zero, ie.. It can be considered that as the level of WTP for the marginal consumer, whose reservation price is just equal to the marginal cost of Halal producers. According to Hoehn and Deaton (2004), in some cases the share of consumers with positive WTP is small compared to the quantity supplied of credence good. Their model consider this as a special case of market saturation in which at the point of price determination for credence good involves WTP equalling zero, ie. , when quantity supplied is more than threshold quantity , specifically for . Hence these provide a basis of which is better suited for the Halal market in the economy of Muslim-minority economies, such as in the United Kingdom and other European countries. Equivalent to Equation (2) in obtaining reservation price schedule for conventional product, the aggregate reservation price schedule for Halal product is, (4) where for , and for . Equation (4) is different from that of Equation (2) as in the former, as there exists a fixed intercept shifter between reservation price loci. This is the WTP a premium for the Halal product. Producers production functions are constant return to scale, but when output increases, input costs rise indicating the supplies for both conventional and Halal product are inelastic. The relationship between marginal cost and quantity supplied by the former products industry is therefore, (5) where is the intercept, is the slope of marginal costs of conventional products industry in terms of the industry output. Hence, the above equation is the supply function for conventional product. On the other hand, the marginal cost and quantity supplied relationship of Halal industry is, (6) where is the intercept, indicates the slope of marginal cost in market share, represents a fixed unit labelling cost. 4.1.1. Equilibrium with certified Halal logo It is obvious that when a producer has a certified (high-quality) logo or labelling, it separate itself from the conventional products which do not have a quality related logo. This is also the case of having certified Halal logo. Again, following model by Hoehn and Deaton (2004) of separating equilibrium, that demand of conventional product market is conditional on the availability of the (relative) Halal products. In other words, conventional market losses the x unit when consumer purchases x unit of Halal goods. Hence, conventional products demand is a conditional, residual demand. In practise, this reflects the demand by secondary (non-Muslim) consumers, as they can consumer either Halal or conventional products but prefer the sooner, in this sense. From the above conditions, the conventional product residual demand is the conventional product demand (from Equation (1)) less consumer demand reallocated to the credence market (first line, second term of Equation (4)). Mathematically this is shown as, (7) where is the prevailing price of Halal product with certified logo. Equivalently, the residual reservation price schedule for conventional products market is the reservation price which is reduced by the amount of conventional good which consumers reallocate to the Halal market, ie. . Hence, the residual price for conventional product is, (8) The second line in the above equation (8) is obtained by adding and subtracting to the first line followed by substituting the reservation price for the marginal Halal consumer. In other words, the intercept for reservation price of conventional aggregate is the marginal reservation price of Halal product adjusted downward by the incremental WTP of for the Halal product. The last line of equation (8) shows that the residual price of conventional product depends on the quantity demanded for its product give or conditional to the shift in quantity demanded for Halal good. A consumer chooses a product that yields the largest relative gain in individual welfare measured by money metric consumer surplus, given by market prices for both types of products (Hoehn and Deaton, 2004). Consumer surplus is the reservation price minus market price of that type of product. It is known that primary (Muslim) consumers will only consume Halal products. On the other hand, the secondary consumers may choose either Halal or conventional products. In doing so, secondary consumers compare the consumer surplus obtained from purchasing Halal product with the opportunity cost of consumer surplus loss by foregoing the purchase of conventional product. If the gain is larger than the opportunity cost, secondary consumer hence purchases Halal products. In other words, Halal product is purchased whenever the difference between surplus gain and opportunity cost is positive, vice versa. Therefore, (9) where, the first line of the above Equation (9) is the net surplus condition. This ensures consumer surplus is maximised by the consumers from their purchases. The second line shows that at a price where the marginal product earns zero rent, Halal market clears. The last two lines indicate the prices and quantities for conventional markets to clear, requiring price to equal marginal costs. The Diagram 3 below (adapted from Hoehn and Deaton, 2004), shows the existence of (separating) market equilibrium for Halal and conventional markets as a result of the introduction of Halal labels. An introduction of primary consumers into the above analysis will distinguish this paper from the works of these authors. The following sub-section provides an analysis that takes into account of non-overlapped consumers. It takes into account of additional demand of the primary consumers (specifically Muslims) whose only be willing to consume Halal products (or nothing if the products are those of conventional non-Halal). 4.1.2. Primary Consumers Demand In reflecting the effect of labelling on primary consumers, another WTP for a premium by Muslim consumers is added to Equation 4. Hence, the aggregate reservation price schedule for Halal product for both primary and secondary consumers becomes, (10) where the superscript B refers to both primary and secondary consumers, and is the additional WTP a premium by primary consumers. Demand by primary consumers does not affect the conventional market as Muslims only consume Halal products. Following from Equation 3, the additional demand by primary market result, (11) where is the WTP by consumer for the Halal credence attribute per unit of the Halal product. In this case, is the WTP by the additional primary market. A shift in supply is expected to cope with the additional primary consumers demand. With the rest of the equations remain the same, as the demand for conventional products are the residue of demand by secondary consumers. These changes are graphically illustrated in the following Diagram 4. 4.2. Producers Motivation for Transformation This section provides an analysis looking at the motivation for producer to transform production of conventional products into that of Halal. From the previous sub-section (4.1.1.), it is clear that due to the existence of willingness to pay (WTP) for Halal product, its market price is greater than that of conventional product price, ie. . Differences in the prices may induce producer to transform their production, however prices alone cannot determine profitability. It is assumed that production of Halal products involve additional costs. The following section provides an analysis in which prices between the two types of products are the same, rather than one having a premium. Furthermore, it is assumed here that only some of the products are transformable. 4.2.1. Homogenous in Pricing The following analysis attempts to model producer incentive to transform production of conventional products into Halal products, particularly in a market where the market prices denoted as , cannot be different between the two types. This requires the prices to be equal, ie. . In this case, one of the assumptions is relaxed, precisely some of the conventional products are transformable into Halal. This model is more likely to suit the producers under franchise market, for example KFC, McDonalds, Subway, etc. This may seem as unprofitable for producers to produce Halal product as production of such goods involve additional labelling cost as mentioned in previous section, while keeping prices unchanged. Hence, the quantity demanded in the market for conventional (non-Halal) franchise products before transformation is, (12) where is the portion of products which can transformed into that of Halal, and is corresponding portion of non-transformable product which cannot be sold in the Halal market, whereas is the quantity demanded for the conventional products in the franchise market. Consequently, the quantity demanded that would have been in the market for Halal products is, (13) where is the perceived quantity demanded of Halal product. The first line of Equation 13 shows that for the producer to transform production into producing only Halal products, the non-transformable portion is removed from the production. Hence, the second line shows that the transformable portion of non-Halal products is transformed into Halal, denoted by. For this reason, producers might not want to transform production into Halal as, as shown in Diagram 5. In this case, producers only consider secondary market for Halal, without looking at primary market potentials. Nonetheless, by introducing Halal products, the producers would gain an additional demand as now, not only secondary consumers (non-Muslims who would consume the products) but also the additional consumptions by primary (Muslim) consumers. Therefore, the real quantity demanded for Halal products of that franchise is, (14) where is the additional WTP for Halal credence by primary consumers. Combining both Equation (3) and Equation (14) give, (15) If the WTP by both secondary and primary consumers are absence, ie., then the above Equation (15) indicate that the quantity demanded (hence supplied) in the franchise market would be the same as those franchises with all conventional products. Nonetheless, in this case is expected as the WTP by secondary and primary consumers are positive, and that the WTP by primary consumers are greater than the former as Muslims are presumed to have higher preferences for consuming Halal products. Hence, , indicating that the quantity demanded in Halal franchise is greater than the quantity demanded in conventional franchise including the opportunity cost of the quantity demanded that would have been gained from producing conventional products, through transformation into Halal franchise. However, in this model, an important assumption must be made, that is the portion of transformable products is sufficiently larger than non-transformable portion, ie. . This is a sufficient reason for producers to gain from production transformation into that of Halal in such franchise market. Similar to Equation 10, the price of Halal franchise is, (16) where and are the WTP a premium for Halal products by secondary and primary consumers respectively. However as the prices of products in the franchise are assumed to be fixed, hence, these WTP would be equal to zero, ie. . Following this, the marginal cost and quantity supplied relationship of Halal industry is the same as that of in Equation (6), (17) where is the intercept, indicates the slope of marginal cost in market share, represents a fixed unit Halal labelling cost or other additional costs incurred in attaining Halal attribute, in other sense. With additional cost, the marginal cost for Halal production franchises are greater that those of conventional franchises, ie.. Nonetheless, this provides a second reason for producers to be willing to transform into Halal production if the weight of additional quantity demanded is greater than the additional labelling cost. This can be seen from the additional producer surplus gain from transformation. Diagram 5 shows a simple illustration for the above analysis, in which the dotted lines are the expected demand and supply after transformation. 4.3. Discussion on Welfare Effects It can be seen that by introducing Halal labelling, it is likely to increase the consumption of such products. In a market where price is not controlled (in Section 4.1.), the introduction of Halal labelling will create a price premium, at the same time, generate greater overall quantity demanded for Halal products. This brings a greater welfare to producers and consumer shown by the producer and consumer surplus respectively. For a market in which introduction of Halal logo does not produces a price premium (in Section 4.2.), such as a franchise, these surpluses are also greater compared to the conventional products, as long as the portion of transformable products dominate non-transformable, otherwise larger opportunity cost incurred from transformation. Hence, welfare in both environments (normal market and franchise) are greater from introduction of Halal products compared those when only conventional products are produced. CHAPTER 5 5.0. Final Annotations This final chapter is divided into two sections. The first section concludes the analysis of this paper where results are briefly discussed. This is followed by a section which covers the policy implications of the analysis, which gives a view of the models if it can be used practically and for future developments. 5.1. Conclusions Credence goods are those which the quality cannot be observed by consumers even after consumption. Among many credence goods, Halal product can be seen as a special type of credence good. Production of Halal products opens up an additional market, which is referred in this paper as primary market of Muslims consumers as they only consume Halal products. Primary market exists with the secondary market of Halal which the later is the result of consumers demand which reallocate from consuming conventional non-Halal products to those of Halal. The analysis is better fit for Muslim-minority economies, such as the United Kingdom. Producer may take the opportunity to produce Halal products based on the higher producer welfare that would be generated from a price premium. This is the situation when the market becomes separated, with price of conventional goods being relatively lower. Adapting to the study of Halal market in similar environment also produces the same outcomes, but with interaction from the effect of primary consumers give clear distinctions that resulted in greater welfare effects In another analysis, different configuration involving the absent of premium pricing from Halal labelling is presented. In this case, initially producers may hesitate to produce or transform production into that of Halal due to the lower expected demand with same price. Nonetheless, this view does not look into additional primary consumers demand. Considering this additional factor, producers would have the incentives to transform their production from conventional to Halal products, but depending on the level or portion of transformable products, as this affects their opportunity costs for transformation. 5.2. Policy Implications The analysis in this paper provides a new window of opportunity for development on the studies of credence goods. The models presented are simple yet have potentials as it describes the current situation with regards to the accelerating growth of Halal food production. The analysis also helps to explain the situation for Halal demand in an economy which is dominated by conventional demand and production. The core of the study can be applied in practise if a producer decides on whether to transform the production into Halal, in order to obtain larger positive gains. However, these models only take into account of honest labelling by producers. Like other credence goods, labelling brings some issues to any credence goods including those of Halal products. These issues can be incorporated for future studies on Halal products as credence goods.

Zionism Essay examples - 1826 Words

Zionism In the years just after World War II, Zionism (the desire to rebuild a Jewish national presence in the Promised Land) became a popular Jewish cause all around the world. Many Jews who were not practicing Judaism at all with religion became involved with the establishment of the State of Israel. Even today, many years after the successful founding of the State of Israel, there are Jews whose only real tie to Judaism is their belief in Zionism and their support for the State of Israel. They are joined by many Jews who are members of synagogues and support a modern Jewish religious movement, but who also find their prime identity as Jews in the Zionist cause. Broadly speaking, Zionists are proud that a small and struggling state†¦show more content†¦Or they may be agnostics, unsure of whether or not God exists. Among religions, Judaism is somewhat unique in that it makes room for both atheists and agnostics to remain Jewish. It is often pointed out that there is no positive commandment in the Torah requiring a Jew to believe in God. When it comes to belief, the Torah commands that Jews adhere to the laws of the covenant, which means that idolatry (the belief in many gods) is forbidden. But a person can theoretically live an exemplary Jewish life without a belief in God. Moreover, connection with the Jewish people is determined by birth, not by belief. If a person is born a Jew (or converts to Judaism), he or she is identified as a Jew. There is no question about this. Even the most religious Jew accepts birth (or conversion) as the only criteria for membership in the Jewish people. ORTHODOX JUDAISM Religious Jews today disagree on what Judaism is and what it should be. Orthodox Jews claim to hold the true religion of Judaism. In fact, Orthodoxy only began to organize and solidify its beliefs in the nineteenth century, in direct response to the Reform movement. To this day, there is less agreement among Orthodox Jews about what being Orthodox means——especially about how particular laws should be followed——than there is disagreement in any of the other modern movements. So, for example, the State of Israel has two â€Å"â€Å"chief†Ã¢â‚¬  rabbis to serve the Orthodox——one ofShow MoreRelatedZionism and Non Zionists Essays1191 Words   |  5 PagesZionism declares that â€Å"the Jews are more than a purely religious body, they are not only a race but also a nation† (Berkowitz 376). Theodor Herzl, the father of political Zionism, states, â€Å"We are a people- one people.† Both Herzl and Berkowitz have interesting key points about a Jewish State, the Jewish religion in general, and how to solve current issues in the religion. A State is formed by a social contract and is still being created today. Rousseau states, â€Å"The conditions of this contract areRead More Theodor Herzl: Father of Zionism? Essay2269 Words   |  10 PagesTheodor Herzl: Father of Zionism? Theodor Herzl is often referred to today as the Father of Zionism, a man known for his role in the establishment of a homeland for the Jewish people. His most famous pamphlet, The Jewish State, inspired thousands of Jewish men and women from across the world, although particularly in Europe, to leave their homes to realize the glory of creating their own homeland in Palestine. While Herzl was originally a believer in the gradual assimilation of German and AustrianRead MoreThe Influence Of Zionism On The Creation Of A Jewish State861 Words   |  4 Pagesthe late 19th and early 20th century an idea began to gain solidarity and momentum, that of Zionism. The idea of Zionism, to create a Jewish state, is arguably one of modern society’s most polarizing and influential movements. Zionism has influenced political, religious, and social groups in a variety of ways that culminated in the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine.(Cohen, week 10) The term Zionism, as it is understood today, began to be used significantly by the political activist Herzl.Read MoreThe Clash Of Zionism And Arab Nationalism Essay1846 Words   |  8 Pages Introduction to Middle East Politics Midterm Essay Minahil Tauseef Clash of Nationalisms The clash of Zionism and Arab nationalism has led to the longest running conflict in the history of the world that shapes the politics of the Middle East to this day. The roots of the modern Arab–Israeli conflict can be found in the rise of Zionism and Arab nationalism towards the end of the 19th century. The source of the conflict is territorial claims over a small piece of land that is the historical homelandRead MoreZionism and the Impact of World War One on the Middle East1534 Words   |  6 Pagesnationalist movement of Zionism emerged out of the Jewish people’s need for a national state of their own. This idea harkens back to the establishment of the Kingdom of Israel after the Exodus. The Holy Land and all of its historic prestige persisted in Jewish culture as they spread throughout the Diaspora for 2000 years. Restrictions and persecution followed the Jewish people as they were met with prejudice throughout Eastern and Western Europe. Organized political Zionism grew from tsarist RussiaRead MoreA Brief Note On The Arab Israeli War1203 Words   |  5 PagesArab-Israeli war the victor was Israel. During this essay the following will be discussed: Zionism, Arab nationalism, and British foreign policy these I believe are the three key causes of the 1948 war. The reason for choosing not just one of these factors to blame is that it was a combination of the three, which has made the Middle East such a hot spot even till now. During the nineteenth century Zionism and Arab nationalism had been rising up with goals of achieving self-determination and emancipationRead MoreIsrael s International Affairs : A Major Issue Of Social Inequality1149 Words   |  5 Pagespoverty line, and ultimately provide a more equal society in which folks that grow up impoverished are not trapped. Question 1. Discuss how the main ideological branches of Zionism (Labor, Revisionist, and Religious) affected the cleavages that we currently observe in the Israeli society. Choose one ideological branch of Zionism and show how it shaped and affected a certain cleavage. If you wish, you can discuss two cleavages, but no more than that. There have been two main cleavages throughout historyRead MoreThe For The International Baccalaureate Diploma1926 Words   |  8 Pagesrate is higher.The topic that I have chosen is Zionism, a movement for the re-establishment and the development and protection of a Jewish nation in what is now Israel. Zionism is an unfamiliar topic for many people and the limited crowd that is well-informed, is informed from solely through one perspective. One of my goals with this assignment is to broaden my perception on global issues, such as Zionism. My perspective personally is against Zionism. Thus, I tried to choose scholars that take theRead MoreThe Rise Of Zionism And Arab Nationalism1407 Words   |  6 PagesThe rise of Zionism and Arab Nationalism in the nineteenth century triggered major political tensions in the region of Palestine. The conflict among the Zionists and Arab Nationalists is primarily due to the politics of territory and is essentially not comprised of religious opposi tion. In fact, before the advent of Zionism and Arab Nationalism, Jews and Palestinians shared a local identity due to mutual tolerances. This identity, which took precedence over religion, created a vivacious communityRead MoreEssay about Nationalist Ideas in the Middle East1484 Words   |  6 Pagesthe Arabs through the revival of Arab thought, while much of the Zionism nationalist ideal is that of establishing a homeland and fleeing anti-Semitism. Both nationalist ideals are similar in that they find nationalism through their history. â€Å"Nationalism, in truth, is the spiritual and historical bond between members of a nation, whom history has stamped in a special manner and has not isolated from the rest of humanity.†2 â€Å"Zionism: the Vision of an Eventual Jewish State† written by Theodor Herzl

Multiple personality disorder Free Essays

Introduction Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD) is one of the dissociative disorders (DD). A dissociative disorder makes a person to experience a transitory adjustment of consciousness. As such, the person has a tendency of diminishing the level of awareness towards the surroundings. We will write a custom essay sample on Multiple personality disorder or any similar topic only for you Order Now Thus, dissociative amnesia and fugue, and depersonalization disorder are the other types of DD. At present, the MPD has been renamed and known in investigative term as the dissociative identity disorder (DID). An MPD or DID shows at least two separate identities of individuality. This as well seizes to manage the persons’ conduct. Richmond (1997) explained that MPD is an abnormal condition in which the personality becomes so fragmented that the various parts cannot even communicate with each other. For the reason that, the personality in MPD is different within the person. This personality can have separate memories, behavior, physical attribution and even gender (http://www.fortea.us/english/psiquitria/mutiple.htm). Furthermore, the personality is the result of a particular problem of an individual to cope with the environment and the new personality is a mechanism created by the psyche to deal with it. The above notion of Richmond (1997) also suggest that a person develops an alters that is, the different personalities that occur to him. This is observe when the person begins to dissociate in order to create new personality as a way of avoidance to a tremendous situation. Most of the researchers agreed to one notion, that MPD or DID has a significant factor during childhood days. It means that this identity disorder had been developed and can be traced out on past experiences that a person undergone; it can be a traumatic one or an extreme stressful events. In addition, Cherry (n.d.) stressed that this disorder occurs when a child is abused at a young age. As a result, his personality splits into several alters to help himself handle and deal with the stress. Hence, it was argued that multiple personality is the result of coping approaches or their means of defense mechanism to keep away from a terrible scenario. Sancar (1994 – 2006) added that these created personalities are then likely to serve as mechanism for coping with situations and events dealing with one particular aspect of the traumatic experience. According to the website (http://www.angelfire.com/nj/Dissociative), DID or MPD is often referred to as a highly creative survival techniques, because it allows an individual to endure hopeless circumstances to preserve some areas of healthy functioning. It serves as the defensive dissociation which becomes reinforced and conditioned. Evidently, dissociative escape is very effective and the patient had already mastered the alters. He may involuntarily use whenever he sense danger or trouble.   This can be concluded that MPD may arise depending on the extent of severe experience and most often referred to as defense mechanism. Causes More research at present explain the concept of MPD or DID. More likely, researches unified in their investigations in tracing out the origin or causes of this disorder. The cause of the disorder is as yet unknown. However, it has been argued by some researchers that the cause of MPD is due to intense stress, trauma, and even abuses. It was assumed that the on-going trauma of abuse, which happens during childhood, just when personality is developing, somehow causes alternate, distinct personalities to form.   Unlike ego, the alternate personalities can and usually do exist completely out of awareness of the main person or of each other. It is as if the alters live in isolated compartments with no communication among them. This is most often the effect of an early awful scenario. Furthermore, a severe childhood trauma or abuses tend to create a mental split or dissociation as a defense against the traumatic situations.   In this way, they could escape the trauma of abuse, at least temporarily by creating new personalities to deal with stress. In addition, Frey (n.d.) added that the severe dissociation which characterized by DID is currently understood to result from an innate impulse to dissociate easily, repeated episodes of severe physical or sexual abuse in childhood, lack of a supportive or comforting person to counteract abusive relative(s), and the influence of other relatives with dissociative symptoms or disorder. Moreover, based on studies women are more likely associated with MPD because they are emotional and are commonly sexually abused than men. Some indisputable cases of DID apparently occur as a result of severe, on-going emotional, sexual, or physical abuse. We also know that DID does not seem to happen as an adult response to trauma; say for instance, men who have been tortured for years in prison apparently do not develop DID. Thus, Adult trauma, however, might bring out other personalities if the adult had developed DID in childhood. The process seem to begin only in children. This makes sense, because childhood is the time of life when personality in general develops in all of us. Symptoms The symptoms (FreeEssays.cc -2003) of an individual with multiple personality disorder are: lack of appropriate emotional response – that is, a person shows an awkward reaction emotionally to a particular events, for example he may project uninterested feeling to a Christmas party or low sense of empathy; memory lose – suggests of forgetting something or not knowing what they have said or done such as lost time or misplacing a thing; feeling dream like; experiencing dissociation which might include dizziness, headaches, numbness in the body; recurrent depression – which tend the person to be sad and despair; anxiety – which the   person felt panic, uneasy, uncomfortable and somehow experiencing phobias; Substance abuse – is a typical scenario were some individuals find it as a substitute or as a defense mechanism to face their concerns, this is because they have this perception in mind that taking the substance make them feel at peace say for instance, a teenager taking marijuana to forget his family problem; eating disorder such as bulimia, anorexia or compulsive overeating– are another way of coping mechanism of a person in which he averts his attention in taking food excessively instead of facing the problem. In other pole, a person has no appetite to take food regularly due to disturbance of the problem; for example, a girl after a break-up with her boy friend eats too much to divert her attention rather than thinking desperately or a fat lady did after six o’clock meal just to reduce weight; a man suffering stress would probably eat too much to pacify his emotional anxiety or can not eat well; sexual dysfunction – may refer or include addiction and avoidance; has low self-esteem – being not motivated, has no desire or interest to life thus the perception is frail; shame – suggest of being socially anxious or a fear of rejection or of what others might think; sleeping disturbances – which includes insomnia, nightmare and sleepwalking; mood swing – in which a person’s atmosphere changes in present setting. Hence, Sancar (1994) added that the co-occurring symptoms and disorder that associated with DID/MPD had been consistently observed in clinical setting that MPD patients suffered such as from panic, anger, rage, sense of unreality, flashbacks, image trauma, and hyper vigilance. People diagnosed with DID also have a secondary diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Thus, another significant symptom of MPD is amnesia which can not be explained by ordinary forgetfulness. It is a state which a person cannot remember anything. Generally speaking, it is a condition that the stored information in the brain with his past experiences disappeared that would certainly give him a picture of a tabula raza (Latin word which means, all is blank and empty). Say for instance, a person with amnesia may loss his memory or any information about his past; he even forgot his name, where he lives, or his family and more forgotten scenario. DID will not be determined if the symptoms will not cause any major disturbances to the person’s life or if they were due to the physiological effects of a substance such as: drugs or alcohol or a general medical condition. This implies that DID/MPD simply be notice when alters ignite in the person’s behavior thus, this is the time were symptoms arises. Therapeutic Treatment The treatment for a personality disorder will take considerable time. A few sessions of cognitive-behavioral treatment will likely not have much effect on deeply rooted unconscious conflicts. This will focus on overcoming all of the unhealthy psychological defense mechanisms that have been built up over a lifetime of emotional pain. This will be accomplished primarily through genuine, honest emotional encounters with the psychologist. In essence, the psychotherapeutic work all depends on the integrity of the psychotherapeutic relationship, through which new, psychologically healthy interpersonal behaviors and healthy boundaries will replace old, unhealthy defense mechanisms (Richmond; 1997-2000). The same as the other personality disorder the MPD or DID is curable. However, it needs to be facilitated or attended with highly qualified practitioner. A thorough and intensive individual psychotherapy or talk therapy. In this case, the session of treatment for psychotherapy is a long-process. It may take a couple of months to a year or more to be concluded. However, a large percentage of people are cured with this method. In this approach, both the person and the therapist must have sense of connection or able to become closer which generate a more trustful companionship. In addition, the other treatment modalities according to Halgins (1997) includes: medication – which some doctors will prescribe antidepressant for DID patient because their alter personalities may have anxiety or mood disorders sometimes patient that are been given medications become psychologically dependent. Hypnotherapy be considered for memory retrieval. The alters may come out and disclose the abusive childhood reminiscences, this is also used for calming and shooting the person during treatment. Is a standard method of treatment with DID patient, because it helps patient recover repressed ideas. It is also an alternative treatment that will help the patient stay clam while pounding out the emotional stresses. Family therapy sessions may also help to end the cycle of abuse. Furthermore, this can be a support group to the client. Because people that are close to him especially his parents and siblings are his nurturing and extending support that would possibly help the patient’s fast recovery. It is as well appropriate to consider the behavioral therapy approaching for DID in order to carry out the clients’ natural environment thus able to stress out the current problems and factors influencing them. For the fact that it can create new problem for learning in the assumption that learning can ameliorate problem behavior. Hence, the treatment for DID will last for five to seven year in adults and usually requires several different treatment methods. BIBLIOGRAPHY A. Book  Halgin P. Richard . 1997. Abnormal Psychology: The Human Experience of Psychology Disorders. Usa: Brown and Benchmark Publishers B. Net Sources Sancar Feyza 1994-2006. Exploring Multiple Personality Disorder. Available: http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/bb/neuro/neuro99/web3/Sancar.html http://www.fortea.us/english/psiquitria/mutiple.htm http://www.angelfire.com/nj/Dissociative/ How to cite Multiple personality disorder, Essay examples

Birches Essay Research Paper After reading this free essay sample

Birchs Essay, Research Paper After reading this verse form, I believe that it can be divided into three specific parts. The scientific account for the visual aspect of birches, Frost # 8217 ; s boyhood fanatasy about their visual aspect, and his present twenty-four hours reading of their visual aspect. In the first subdivision, Frost explains the birches visual aspects scientifically. He implys that natural phenomenons make the subdivisions of the birch trees sway. He explains that ice storms, which is a feature of New England conditions, can roll up on the subdivisions and do them to go heavy and flexing. ( For those of ya # 8217 ; ll non familiar with the visual aspect of the bark of the birch, chink here. ) Birchs have a black background with crackled snow white bark on top of the black bark. It has an unusual visual aspect because both the black and the white are visable. Frost offers many suggestions for their visual aspect. It possibly due to the ice breakage that is burdened on the bark. The zephyr causes the ice to travel and check certain parts of the bark, making the greaves consequence. # 8220 ; As the [ ice ] splash clefts and madden their enamel. # 8221 ; He besides compares this image to that of interrupting glass and compares it to the # 8220 ; dome of Eden # 82 21 ; shattering. I enjoy how he offers such different readings for the visual aspect of the bark. My personal favourite is the smashing of the dome in Eden. I think this creates a graphic image for the reader. He goes on to state that one time the subdivisions are dead set, they neer return wholly unsloped once more, but they are so flexible that they neer break. # 8221 ; You may see their short pantss curving in the woods/ Years afterwards, draging their foliages on the ground. # 8221 ; These are some of the natural phenomenons that Frost references to explicate the visual aspect of Birch trees. Frost so goes on to offer a more fantasy-like reading that he knows is non the existent ground for their visual aspect, but it is inventive and originative. He imagines small male childs could hold caused this bending of the subdivisions to go on because they were singing and playing on them. He so begins to state a fable-like narrative that could explicate their visual aspect. He describes a immature male child that lives in a rural district, perchance a farm, that goes out to make his jobs, like bringing the cattles, but gets side tracked by both the beauty of the forests and his wanting to play. Because the small male child is in a privy environment, he is forced to entertain himself. Therefore, he became accustom erectile dysfunction to playing on his father’s trees. One by one, he would suppress them all. He did this on such a frequent footing that he took the stiffness out of them and caused them to flex. Here Frost is offering a far-fetched romantic suggestion like some of Aesop’s fabrications. It was the boy’s unworried mode of amusement that was an alibi for the bending of the trees. He so goes on to state that he learned many valuable lessons singing on the trees. These could be both lessons covering with life every bit good as how to play on the trees decently. As all the trees became dead set, he learned to swing from tree to corner, but leaping off before they touched the land. In this paragraph, Frost explores a male child, possibly his ain, phantasies with the birch trees. He offers a more child-like attack to explicate the visual aspect of the trees. The concluding portion of the poem trades with Frost # 8217 ; s adult positions about birch trees and how he relates it to his life. He is reflecting back to a male child # 8217 ; s innoncent childhood experience. Although we are non certain that the male child described in the verse form is Frost, it is definately a possibility because he grew up in New England, an country with many birch trees. At the terminal of the verse form, Frost longs to return back in clip to this unworried life. Frost says that whenever his life becomes hard and confusing, he wishes that he could merely swing carefreely from subdivision to subdivision as he did when he was a kid. In fact, he enjoyed this epoch in his life so much that he is willing to be # 8220 ; reborn # 8221 ; to see this phase of his life once more. Don # 8217 ; T concern, he is non self-destructive, he merely longs to revisit his childhood yearss, where his life was peaceable, merriment, and carefree. He does non desire to merely m erely die, but # 8220 ; dice, and be reborn again. # 8221 ; He is non rejecting Earth, because he likes Earth and all that it has to offer. # 8220 ; Earth # 8217 ; s the right topographic point for love: / I don # 8217 ; T know where it # 8217 ; s likely to travel better. # 8221 ; Although he has grown up, he is still a portion of this fantasy universe that he would be content # 8220 ; mounting # 8221 ; birches his full life. He uses the image that the top of the trees represent heaven, and the more he climbs the closer he is to making his dream. However, he does non desire to make heaven right this instant, so the bending of the tree would direct him back down to earth, or world. # 8220 ; But dipped its top and put me down again/ That would be good both traveling and coming. # 8221 ; But he would be absolutely content with his life being a # 8220 ; swinger of birches. # 8221 ; Frost was a bitchin cat.

Reviewing The Movie Spiderman English Literature Essay Essay Example

Reviewing The Movie Spiderman English Literature Essay Paper In the film Spiderman 2 ( 2004 ) , Peter Parker, aka Spiderman, gets in to a conversation with Dr. Otto Octavious, the scientist, who subsequently morphs into the ace scoundrel Doc Ock. Dr. Octavious Tells Peter about his fiancee, a literature pupil, when they met in college and how she attempted to larn scientific discipline for his interest and how he tried to larn literature for hers. She was more successful and he less, as he explains to Peter, She was analyzing T.S. Eliot, and, compared to science, Eliot is really complicated ( Murphy ) . A similar perplexity ( or bias, for that affair ) dovetails literary scholarship on Eliot, more specifically in relation to The Waste Land. This paper is non an effort to do things easier or to find a synoptically consistent logic behind The Waste Land. Such an effort would be partly successful, but the chief accent of this paper is to find and reason for some markers or critical attacks that dissect the structural anatomy of the verse form. We will write a custom essay sample on Reviewing The Movie Spiderman English Literature Essay specifically for you for only $16.38 $13.9/page Order now We will write a custom essay sample on Reviewing The Movie Spiderman English Literature Essay specifically for you FOR ONLY $16.38 $13.9/page Hire Writer We will write a custom essay sample on Reviewing The Movie Spiderman English Literature Essay specifically for you FOR ONLY $16.38 $13.9/page Hire Writer The main motivation for such an effort is to detect critical attacks that can be applied to the whole verse form to earn different readings of the verse form. Eliot s attempts in the verse form have laid much of the accent on the act of reading, and instead than the complexnesss of the verse form that conjure to ebb reader involvement ( as immediate reappraisals of the verse form suggested ) , I argue that the verse form, in its disconnected ego, is able to take the reader deeper into the poetic experience. The first attack is instead theoretical, based chiefly on the thought of historical sense that Eliot emphasised in his essay Tradition and the Individual Talent. The 2nd attack is chiefly structural, based on the thought of deducing intending between the experiences of authorship and reading. Outlaying these attacks, it is deserving adverting that there have been legion cases in the research where these attacks have overlapped, with positive consequences that have eased the analys is. The Waste Land, in my foremost statement, is a catalytic entity. This simple derivation, of class, draws from Eliot s modern-day times and the societal aura after the Great War. But other than that, in composing the lines of the verse form, Eliot has stressed upon the cyclic nature of historical events that an single must see in her/ his life-time. The grounds for such a claim may be drawn from the verse form. First, allow us see the abstract nature of the verse form ; 2nd, the broken fragments and 3rd, the equivocal and frequently altering points of narrative. All, in their blazing manner defy a additive comprehension of the verse form. This would propose that the procedure of composing involved an impersonal idea procedure that stressed more on the thoughts of abstract feelings instead than a personal purpose of look. The response to such a method of composing would non be what is the poet stating? but what is the verse form stating? . More significance can be derived from repl ying the later inquiry than seeking to bracket the verse form within conventional grounds of composing poesy. Hence, it becomes clear that the procedure of creative activity, on Eliot s portion, is purely catalytic, non pulling merely on modern-day history, but pulling from a tradition of historic rhythms that have enriched the modern-day mind. These conform closely to Eliot s claims in theory in the essay Tradition and the Individual Talent. The same statement can be farther elaborated if we consider these lines from The Waste Land: Jerusalem Athens Alexandria Vienna London Unreal ( 374- 376, From What the Thunder Said ) . The symbols of fallen civilizations and falling civilizations come together in the infinite of two lines to show Eliot s feelings in the third- Unreal . It is a procedure of distilling history and clip within the infinite of a individual mention to convey a remarkable feeling amongst a montage of looks. The thought is to emphasize on the narrowness of the separation of tradition ( in my statement history ) and the adult male who suffers or the life poet with a to the full rounded personality ( Eliot ) . The vault of intending that lines similar to the above quoted lines in The Waste Land carry are because of the adept narrowness of this separation from tradition ( history ) that Eliot strives to accomplish. Any creative activity of poesy, as he stresses, is an add-on to the tradition in a dynamic relationship, and hence, the same tradition ( and history ) act as the bare castanetss of The Waste Land. For the comprehension of significance, this posit of structural anatomy of th e verse form, as I argue, is the primary stepping rock. From this theoretical base point, it is now possible to manage the structural statements refering The Waste Land in a directional position. In the old statement, the keywords to the statement were tradition and history. In turn uping The Waste Land in the modernist environment a similar historical position is ineluctable, but this statement largely concerns itself with sociological forms. In analyzing the disconnected construction of the verse form, the general concern is necessarily the broken or endangered topic of European civilization exposed to devastation after the First World War, and it should be so. From this same platform, if this analysis were to delve farther in to each fragment of event in the verse form and non needfully the five defined parts of the verse form, the job of narrative would halt at one point: socio- psychological atomization of the single topic. This statement is debatable for the simple ground that by turn uping the said atomization in the individual top ic , it brings into inquiry the auctorial voice of all the 434 lines every bit good as the remarkable voices of narrating characters inside the assorted fragments of the verse form ( and non merely the demarcated five parts, henceforward intending the same ) . The solution would be to get down with a broader spectrum and contract down to the two sets of individual topic . To state that structurally the verse form is determined by a common socio- psychological atomization is to get down with the modern sociological theory of atomization that states three phenomena of atomization ( Keunen ) . First, a division of the societal field in assorted subsystems, besides called functional distinction , 2nd ; the increasing tensenesss with moral discourse straight related to functional distinction, and 3rd ; the atomization of the subjective ( self- ) perceptual experience. In instance of Eliot, as we have seen in the first statement, the principal concern is with history and tradition, and therefore I infer a concern with civilization, the medium of historical heritage. Powered with this background, the statement is simple: in the commoditised modernist minute, money flowed easier than civilization and for Eliot and his conservative historicity, it was a baleful minute. Relatively, it was besides a pandemonium of feelings and interactions that could easy take to the atomization of experience. This is non to propose that The Waste Land is wholly a reactionist poetic creative activity, instead it is to propose ( as Keunen points out in relation to the modernist novel ) that for Eliot such an experience evaluated to cultural pessimism and utmost conservative reaction hovering between utopia and desperation ( Keunen ) . The consequence is the metempsychosis and Resurrection of decay in the verse form, from anticipating a cadaver to shoot ( line 71- 72, from The Burial of the Dead ) to the rat s back street where the dead work forces lost their castanetss ( lines 115- 116, from A Game of Chess ) . The statement, hence, tries to get at a valid decision to explicate the disconnected nature of the verse form and postulates that the fragments be analysed as fragments and non as a complete whole. As for the single topics of the fragments of the verse form, Eliot s concern is subjected to the places of narrative within the construction of the verse form. The general concern of the larger cultural and societal pandemonium is sublimated in the signifiers of subjective memory that is someway unqualified to come to footings with the functional distinction. In the construction of the verse form, this is expressed in the word picture of gender ( lines 222- 256, from The Fire Sermon ) , neurasthenia ( lines 111- 134, from A Game of Chess ) , nostalgia ( lines 8- 18, from The Burial of the Dead ) and the socially apparent quandary of category ( lines 77- 107 and lines 139- 172, from A Game of Chess ) . In all four cases ( and many more ) the finding factor that promises significance is the map and usage of memory. Each in their subjective manner tells a different narrative, but each is derived from the modern experience. This is an experience that does non assure significance as a inc orporate whole, but when dealt with abstractly, has a significance of its ain, in its ain right and context. The map of memory is to warrant its presence in the verse form as a whole, or such experiences would be lost in the pandemonium of societal atomization. Structurally, hence, the map of the socio- psychological atomization serves the intent of Eliot s purpose. He provides a poetic merchandise of his times but non confined to the contexts of his clip entirely, he draws from a history yesteryear and modern-day but avoids major conformations of historical philistinism. The disposed decision for this statement can be derived from one of Eliot s ain theories sing the societal map of poesy, one that deals with the map of history from a ulterior work, The Social Function of Poetry ( 1945 ) . There, he expounds the thought that the poet s existent protagonism of or assail on a peculiar societal attitude can non represent poesy s societal map for the obvious and simple ground that the poesy remains to be of some value to humanity long after the specific societal causes that may hold inspired it-if, for that affair, there go on to hold been any-have rather literally go lost to history. ( T. Eliot ) The nature scholarship related to The Waste Land since 1922 have served to ease the procedure ( or perplex farther! ) of geting at a consensus of significance. The cardinal job has been the break in the flow of information defying absolute additive outline, in the words of a critic, the modernist work stymies the readerly impulse to clean up up loose terminals ( McDonald ) . I argue that for The Waste Land there are no loose terminals. The old statements refering atomization and pulling on a tradition of history and literature by virtuousness of intertextuality at least turn out that each fragment has a presence of its ain in the verse form. A point in concern in the thesis of this paper has been the imbrication of the analysis of the two cardinal statements for positive consequences. The convergence is best described in these undermentioned footings: a few fragments could be added before the first published version of the verse form ( 1922 ) , or in the center of the verse form or at the terminal or at any other point in the verse form without restricting the construction of the verse form, or the tradition cradling the verse form or the derivational significances of the verse form. This is a debatable statement to do because it brings into inquiry the really nature and being of a work of art. The statement can be sustained, nevertheless by borrowing an component of analysis straight out of Saussure s theory of the duality of linguistic communication in such a manner that both the nature and being of the verse form can be sustained in the visible radiation of the present statement. Saussure described linguistic communication based on a syntagmatic relationship ( Ferdinand de Saussure ( Trans. W.Baskin ) ) , where each mark contributes something to the significance as a whole and each contrasting with all other marks in the linguistic communication. To this syntagmatic relationship, marks could be added to accommodate convenience. Over and above this relationship, there is present the paradigmatic relationship ( Ferdinand de Saussure ( Trans. W.Baskin ) ) , where sub- sets of marks could be substituted in topographic point of the outstanding marks of the syntag matic construction. In The Waste Land, it has already been established that single fragments exist in the freedom of their ain significance, lending to the larger sequence of significance, but there is no additive synoptic significance as a whole or one unit of significance. Hence, borrowing from Saussure s theory, it is possible to reason that fragments could be added to the original verse form ( 1922 ) without restricting the construction of the verse form or the tradition behind it. The same can barely be said of canceling any fragment from the verse form for the obvious ground that each published fragment ( and non the demarcated five ) serves some intent in the single significance and the complete sequence of significance. Editorial intercession, most famously that of Ezra Pound s has already curtailed the original composing and for the interest of the published one, the lesser said the better. For his ain poetical record, the thought of historical sense that he propagated in the essay Tradition and the Individual Talent is self apparent in the verse form. Every complete piece of good literature would be an add-on to the extremum of tradition ( T. S. Eliot ) . What this essay proves is that alternatively of trying intending derivation in the additive manner, which is non ever possible for The Waste Land, it is however a meaningful experience of reading in the disconnected whole of the verse form. The critical attacks, specifically the thought of tradition and an penetration into the structural anatomy of the verse form serve the intent giving way to nearing the verse form with certain tools in the act of reading. The key to this method of analysis has been the importance of readerly consciousness that Eliot has stressed in his legion other critical plants and what Eliot demands of it. In his composing of The Waste Land Eliot digs up the buried castanetss of the dead work forces and finds more, does more. It is for the critic to delve up those castanetss, a procedure of delving that might perchance neer terminal. The excavation, at least, serves as a pace stick for understanding and deducing intending out of The Waste Land.